Customer Experience Manager - Insurance Sector

  • Massenhove Recruitment Limited
  • Nov 21, 2026
Full time Call Centre / CustomerService Management

Job Description

Customer Experience Manager

Location: UK

Industry: Insurance / Motor Insurance Broking

The Opportunity

We are looking for an experienced Customer Experience Manager to lead and develop a customer service team within a busy insurance business.

This is a hands-on management role combining customer experience, team leadership, operational performance and credit control responsibilities. You will be responsible for ensuring customers receive an efficient, fair and professional service while maintaining strong controls around arrears, aged debt, premium finance and insurer payments.

The successful candidate will be equally comfortable coaching a customer service team, handling complex complaints and reviewing financial reports to ensure outstanding balances are managed effectively.

This is an excellent opportunity for someone who enjoys taking ownership, improving processes and making a genuine difference to both customer outcomes and business performance.

Key Responsibilities

Customer Experience & Service Delivery

  • Lead, motivate and develop the customer service team, covering inbound and outbound customer contact.
  • Monitor service performance, including call answer rates, abandoned calls, response times, first-contact resolution and customer satisfaction.
  • Improve the customer journey, particularly around mid-term adjustments, cancellations and customer retention.
  • Handle escalated complaints, aiming for first-contact resolution wherever possible.
  • Oversee call monitoring, quality assurance and file audits, providing coaching and feedback to improve service standards.
  • Embed FCA Consumer Duty requirements, ensuring customers are treated fairly and vulnerable customers receive appropriate support.
  • Manage team rotas and resources to ensure service levels are maintained.

Credit Control & Finance Responsibilities

  • Manage aged debt, reviewing outstanding balances, prioritising recovery activity and reporting trends to senior management.
  • Take ownership of arrears management, including payment reminders, customer contact and escalation procedures.
  • Manage relationships with premium finance providers, resolving queries relating to agreements, missed payments, cancellations and refunds.
  • Check insurer premiums, fees and commission to ensure figures are accurate before settlement.
  • Oversee the credit control inbox, ensuring queries are allocated and resolved within agreed timescales.
  • Work closely with the finance team on reconciliations and identifying potential financial risks.
  • Support customers experiencing financial difficulties, agreeing appropriate payment arrangements and ensuring fair treatment.

Leadership, Compliance & Improvement

  • Set objectives, conduct regular one-to-ones and manage team performance, training and development.
  • Ensure compliance with FCA regulations, Consumer Duty, UK GDPR and internal procedures.
  • Produce management information covering customer service performance, complaints, arrears and aged debt.
  • Identify opportunities to improve processes, systems and operational efficiency.
  • Act as the escalation point for complex customer service and credit control issues.

About You

We are looking for someone with a strong background in customer service management within insurance broking, insurance or financial services.

You will ideally have:

  • Previous experience managing a customer service or operations team within insurance or financial services.
  • Working knowledge of credit control, aged debt, arrears management or debt recovery.
  • An understanding of premium finance arrangements, including payments, cancellations and refunds.
  • Experience checking premium figures, reconciling accounts and resolving financial discrepancies.
  • A good understanding of FCA regulations and Consumer Duty.
  • Strong leadership, coaching and communication skills.
  • Good Excel skills and experience using CRM and broker management systems.
  • A methodical approach, excellent attention to detail and the ability to manage competing priorities.

Desirable Experience

  • Background in UK motor insurance broking.
  • Experience using Open GI.
  • Knowledge of insurer statements and settlement processes.
  • Cert CII, Diploma in Insurance or a relevant finance/credit control qualification.

The Ideal Candidate

You will be a confident, hands-on manager who combines a genuine passion for customer service with sound financial and operational awareness.

You will be comfortable having difficult conversations, supporting customers in challenging circumstances, developing people and ensuring the business maintains effective financial controls.

If you are an experienced insurance customer service manager looking for a varied role with responsibility across customer experience, team leadership and credit control, we would like to hear from you.

Along with our client, we are committed to a diverse workforce and as such recruit from a wide available pool of talent, with the hiring, assessment and selection process being fair, free from bias and one which ensures the right person is selected for the job, based on merit. We treat colleagues, candidates, clients, and business partners with equality, fairness and respect, regardless of their age, disability, race, religion or belief, gender, sexual orientation, marital status or family circumstances.

A copy of our D&I policy can be made available upon request.